Subscription Box vs. Buying Individual Figures: Which is Best for Collectors?

For figure collectors, one of the biggest decisions is whether to buy individual figures or subscribe to a figure subscription box service. Since collecting has become more popular over the years, some companies have found a niche in offering services for these individuals. I’ve even seen boxes that focus on one specific IP!

However, regardless of where you get your figures, it is important to be aware of scams. Always be on guard if someone states they live in Japan and will hunt down your figure for a finder’s fee, or if the website claims to be based in Japan but their business address is located in China.

After you’ve sent your money (usually through wire transfer), you won’t hear from the seller again. It’s always so disappointing and frustrating to fall for these scammers, but don’t be too hard on yourself—they have gotten really good at appearing like a legitimate company.

Anyway, using a subscription box service or buying figures individually has its own advantages and drawbacks, making it essential to determine which approach aligns best with your collecting goals. Whether you’re looking to build a massive collection, find rare pieces, or simply enjoy the surprise of new figures, this guide will help you decide which method is right for you.

Subscription Box Collecting: The Pros and Cons

Pros:

1. Convenience and Surprise:

– Subscription boxes deliver figures straight to your door, eliminating the need to search for individual pieces.

– The surprise factor makes it fun and exciting—you never know what exclusive or limited-edition item you might receive!

2. Potential for Exclusive and Rare Figures:

– Some subscription boxes include figures that are exclusive to the service, making them highly sought-after by collectors. These collaborations are definitely sought after and can be limited too, adding more value to your collection.

– Rare or convention-exclusive figures may occasionally be included, adding value to your collection.

3. Cost-Effectiveness:

– Subscription boxes often bundle figures at a lower overall price than buying them individually.

– Discounts and bundled savings are common in multi-box subscriptions.

4. Themed Collections:

– Boxes often follow specific themes (e.g., anime, gaming, superheroes), helping collectors build cohesive collections over time.

Cons:

1. Lack of Control Over Selections:

– Since subscription boxes contain random or pre-selected figures, you might receive characters or series you’re less interested in or that you have no interest in. This sometimes makes a bit of extra work for the collector, having to resell them locally.

– Duplicate figures can be a risk if you’re already an avid collector.

2. Long-Term Commitment:

– Some subscription services require multi-month commitments, which may not suit collectors who prefer one-time purchases.

– With a subscription, it can also be difficult to cancel once you’ve reached your goal with that service, and you may get stuck paying when you no longer want it.

3. Potential for Unwanted Fandoms and Fakes:

– Mixed-fandom boxes may include figures from series you don’t follow or enjoy.

– Some large subscription services cut costs by including figures that are not licensed by the IP holders. This helps with their costs and can make the box seem like a great deal, but for any collector, having fakes in a collection isn’t the ultimate goal.

Buying Individual Figures: The Pros and Cons

Pros:

1. Complete Control Over Your Collection:

– You can hand-pick the exact figures you want, ensuring your collection matches your tastes perfectly.

– No risk of receiving duplicates or unwanted characters.

2. Better Investment Potential:

– Carefully selecting figures gives you the opportunity to invest in rare, high-value pieces that appreciate over time.

– You can monitor figure market trends and buy at the right moment.

3. Flexibility in Spending:

– You can choose to buy only when you find figures you truly want, without being tied to a subscription schedule.

– You are able to save for larger figure purchases outside of the subscription box “bundle” deals.

Cons:

1. Higher Costs:

– Individual figures, especially rare or imported ones, often come with a higher price tag.

– Shipping costs can add up when buying figures one at a time.

2. Time-Consuming:

– Searching for specific figures, comparing prices, and hunting for deals can be time-intensive.

3. Limited Availability of Exclusives:

– Exclusive figures from subscription boxes or convention releases may be difficult to obtain individually and can be significantly more expensive on the secondary market.

4. Potential of Being Scammed:

– Buying individual figures can open you up to scams, as some people claim to offer figures for sale from their collection overseas (China & Japan).

BUT there is another option! – The Big Pros of My Anime Box

Tailored to Your Preferences:

– Unlike standard subscription boxes, a personalized service like mine ensures you receive figures that align with your favorite fandoms and characters.

– With My Anime Box, you fill out a detailed form about your preferences, and I hand-pick figures that match your interests, making every box feel custom-made.

High-Quality Selection:

– Our service includes a single box to try, which includes a standard figure and a premium figure—so no worries about being stuck in a subscription.

– For die-hard collectors, they can get the annual package that includes 4 boxes total. The annual box offers the same standard and premium figures; however, a bonus item is included as an extra thank you!

Exclusive and Premium Figures:

– Since I curate each box based on your preferences, you’re more likely to receive figures you’ll treasure rather than random, less-desirable ones.

– All figures are vetted for authenticity and come from licensed wholesalers—no chance of getting a fake with My Anime Box. I want the best for my collectors!

Summary

Both subscription boxes and individual figure purchases offer unique advantages for collectors. Subscription boxes are ideal for those who enjoy variety, surprises, and the possibility of exclusive figures, while buying individual figures offers more control and precision for collectors seeking specific pieces.

Personalized services like My Anime Box combines the best of both worlds—offering surprise and exclusivity with the added benefit of being tailored to your preferences. Ultimately, the best option depends on your collecting goals, budget, and preferences. Whichever route you choose, happy collecting!